Wind turbines kill lots of birds, notably eagles and different raptors. The precise quantity is unknown, as a result of lots of the world’s wind farms don’t monitor fowl deaths. One mitigation concept to scale back these numbers—and assuage a political argument towards wind generators—is gaining traction: Paint one turbine blade black. Ecologist Roel May spoke with IEEE Spectrum about his 11-year study to scale back raptor deaths, and his shock on the lukewarm reactions from wind-turbine engineers.
Roel Might
Roel May is a senior analysis scientist specializing in renewable energy impacts and mitigation on the Norwegian Institute for Nature Analysis (NINA) in Trondheim, Norway.
How dangerous are wind turbines for birds?
Roel Might: It relies upon lots on the place you place the generators, and whether or not there’s breeding or foraging areas close by, and the species of birds. For those who put wind generators smack in the course of a susceptible inhabitants, the impact could be fairly massive. That’s what occurred in Norway on the island of Smøla, which is a scorching spot for white-tailed eagles. That’s the place we did our examine.
Why are eagles vulnerable to wind generators?
Might: Raptor species like eagles are superb at flying, however they don’t look straight forward; they appear down on the floor for prey. They like to make use of updrafts to soar, however updrafts are frequent close to ridges the place wind circumstances are good for generators. In order that’s a nasty mixture.
Does the wind-turbine sort make a distinction?
Might: Bigger generators kill extra birds as a result of their blades take up extra space. However the place wind generators are smaller, there’s usually extra of them, so these wind farms might find yourself killing extra birds than farms with fewer, bigger generators, a minimum of onshore. Offshore wind farms are more durable to check: You possibly can’t rely the precise variety of birds that die as a result of you may’t discover them; they fall into the ocean they usually’re gone. Some researchers are attempting to file collisions with bird radar, cameras, and different programs.
You discovered that portray one blade black resulted in a 70 % decline in fowl deaths. Ought to all wind farms be doing this?
Might: Our examine is one thing that must be repeated in different places as a result of there are probably site-specific and species-specific results. A bunch in the Netherlands painted blades and hasn’t seen a transparent impact. So we’d like extra research. There’s one examine getting into South Africa the place they painted a blade red, and a few others which arestarting in Wyoming, Italy, and Spain. The United Kingdom is planninga pilot project for offshore generators. However these research are laborious to do as a result of the operator has to get exemptions from laws to color the blades and rent licensed painters who can rappel up and down. And it takes lots of time. We collected information on eagles in Smøla for seven years earlier than the blades have been painted. After we painted, we spent 4 extra years finding out the results.
How did engineers reply to your examine?
Might: Lots of people from turbine producers requested if I had thought of the technical implications of this. I hadn’t, as a result of I’m an ecologist, not an engineer. Apparently black blades will warmth up greater than white blades, which can trigger structural results. And the black paint is made with carbon, which might have an effect on the turbine’s efficiency when hit by lightning. Engineers don’t like that. So we have to overcome these disciplinary silos and work collectively to develop useful mitigation measures.
This text seems within the June 2025 print subject as “Roel Might.”
From Your Web site Articles
Associated Articles Across the Internet
